Greenwashing
Definition
Greenwashing means presenting a company or a product as better for the environment than the facts can prove. In France, a false or misleading environmental claim is a misleading commercial practice, punishable under the Consumer Code.
How to spot it
Greenwashing is not always a lie. It often starts with a gap between the message and the evidence. Its most common forms:
- the vague word: “green”, “sustainable”, “responsible”, with no precise fact next to it;
- the halo effect: a real but marginal action, presented as if it summed up the whole business;
- the distant promise: a target twenty years away, with no milestones and no verification;
- the in-house label: a logo created by the company and presented as a certification;
- offsetting presented as reduction: purchased carbon credits described as a cut in the product’s emissions.
What the law says
Article L121-2 of the French Consumer Code treats as misleading any practice based on false or misleading claims, in particular about a product’s environmental impact or the scope of the advertiser’s environmental commitments. Both references were added by Law No. 2021-1104 of 22 August 2021, known as the Climate and Resilience Law. Article L132-2 makes these practices a criminal offence and raises the maximum fine when they rest on an environmental claim.
The rule also applies when you address professional buyers (article L121-5). Claiming in an advertisement that a product is carbon neutral is also governed by article L229-68 of the French Environmental Code.
At EU level, Directive (EU) 2024/825 of 28 February 2024 bans several kinds of wording, including generic claims that a company cannot back with recognised excellent environmental performance. Member States were due to apply it from 27 September 2026; as of 20 November 2026, France has not yet transposed it. Our article on communicating CSR commitments without greenwashing sets out where the texts stand.
Why the press pays attention
Journalists who cover the environment receive many commitment announcements. They ask for the source figure, the scope, a third party’s opinion. An NGO, a competitor or a reader can also point out the gap between words and facts.
A release that overstates does not just lose you an article. It can produce the opposite article, about that very gap, and that piece can keep surfacing in searches for your name for a long time.
The limits of the word
The term has become an easy accusation, sometimes aimed at a sincere but imperfect effort. The answer is not silence, which has its own name, greenhushing, but communication sized to the evidence.
Greenwashing is not a legal category: the law speaks of misleading commercial practices. Whether a given sentence crosses the line is a question for a lawyer, not for a communicator.
In practice
Before an announcement, professional practice is to start from the evidence: a report, an assessment, a certification issued by a third party. The message is written afterwards, no bigger than what the evidence supports.
Every figure carries its scope, period and method in the same sentence. The spokesperson prepares for questions about what has not yet been achieved.
The environmental claims in a press release go through legal review as soon as they concern a product or an offer.
Frequently asked questions
Can a press release amount to greenwashing?
Yes. The rules on misleading commercial practices are not limited to advertising, and a release that promotes a product or an offer can fall under them. Have its environmental claims reviewed by your lawyer before sending it.
Are companies that sell to other businesses concerned?
Yes. Article L121-5 of the French Consumer Code extends the rules on misleading practices to practices aimed at professionals. A claim made to business buyers must be as solid as one made to the general public.
What is the difference between greenwashing and greenhushing?
Greenwashing overstates what a company does for the environment. Greenhushing keeps quiet about what it does, for fear of criticism. Both deprive the public of accurate information.