Skip to content
Go to the Press Room
Press relations

How to choose a press relations agency: criteria, questions and pricing

Six criteria for comparing press relations agencies, the questions to ask in a meeting, the red flags and the prices, and how an agency compares with a freelancer or an in-house press officer.

Aymeric
AymericCo-founder of 425PPM
10 min read
8 conseils pour bien choisir son agence de relations presse
Contents

Choosing a press relations agency means entrusting it, for several months, with how journalists will discover your company. Sales presentations all look alike; what sets agencies apart can be checked elsewhere, and this article tells you where. A word of transparency: 425PPM is a press relations agency, and what follows applies to us as much as to anyone else.

Here you will find what to prepare before approaching agencies, the six criteria that separate them, the questions to ask in a meeting, the red flags, the choice between an agency, a freelancer and an in-house press officer, and pricing. If you are new to the subject, start with our press relations guide (in French), which explains how PR works.

What should you prepare before approaching agencies?

You don't choose an agency in the abstract, but for a goal. Announcing a funding round, establishing an executive as a voice in their sector, supporting sales, helping with recruitment: each goal calls for different media, different formats and a different pace. Write yours down in one sentence, with a deadline.

Next, check that you have material to work with. An agency works with your news: figures, clients, launches, studies, public stances. With nothing to announce for six months, even a very good agency will have little to offer journalists; in that case, you are better off laying the groundwork first, meaning your messages, your proof points, your spokespeople and your press kit.

Finally, put this framing in writing: context, goal, targets, timeline, budget. Two pages are enough, and they make the proposals comparable with one another. Our article on the PR agency brief in 12 questions (in French) gives you the template to fill in.

Which criteria really separate agencies?

Six criteria make the difference between two agencies that promise the same thing. None of them can be judged from a brochure: each one is checked in a meeting, with examples to back it up.

1. A specialization that matches your sector

An agency that already follows your market knows the journalists who cover it, the trade shows that matter, the sensitive topics and what makes real news. It gets up to speed faster and suggests credible angles. A generalist agency is fine for a general-interest topic; on a technical or regulated subject, such as energy, healthcare, industry or finance, it will spend its first weeks learning what a specialist agency already knows.

The simplest test: ask which journalists the agency would contact first about your topic, and why. An agency that knows your market will cite names and recent articles.

2. An identified team that will actually do the work

Sometimes a partner pitches the offer and then a junior staffer, working alone, sends the emails. An agency is only as good as the team assigned to your account. Ask who will write your story pitches and call the journalists, how much experience they have, and how many other clients they handle at the same time. Have their names written into the contract.

Whether the agency is large or small, also ask where you will stand: will you be a priority client or one account among many? And trust the quality of the exchanges from the very first meeting: you will be working with these people for months, and they will speak to journalists on your behalf.

3. A clear method and clear reporting

A serious agency explains how it gets from your news to an article: choice of angles, list of target journalists, pace of pitches and follow-ups, progress reviews. It can also tell you when an announcement will not interest the press, rather than sending it anyway. That is a sign of expertise, not of unwillingness.

Ask to see a real report, anonymized if necessary: topics pitched, journalists contacted, responses received, coverage obtained. A report that only lists what was sent says nothing about what worked. Also be wary of reporting built around advertising value equivalency (AVE), which converts an article into the price of an ad without saying anything about its effect on your customers: the metrics that replace it (in French) are more useful.

4. An up-to-date media list

Journalists often change beats, publications or careers. A list bought once a year sends your stories to people who have moved on, and every poorly targeted pitch wears down your credibility a little more with those who remain. A good agency identifies who is writing about your topic today by reading what gets published, and targets a few well-chosen journalists rather than a list of several hundred contacts.

Ask how the agency keeps its media list up to date, and how many journalists it would target for your first announcement.

5. Verifiable results

A wall of logos proves nothing: it tells you who signed, not what was achieved. Ask for real, dated articles in media you read, and a case study close to your situation. Then check that these articles exist, and ask to speak to two clients, including one who ended the collaboration.

6. A clear pricing model

Monthly retainer, one-off project or pay-per-placement: each model has its own logic. Pay-per-placement seems reassuring, but it pushes the agency toward media that publish easily, not necessarily the ones your customers read. Whatever the model, before signing, get clarity on what is included, the length of the commitment, the exit terms and what is billed on top (media training, press events, studies, translation). A quote that talks about “visibility” without any deliverables can't be compared with anything.

What questions should you ask in a meeting?

These eight questions fit into a one-hour meeting. A vague answer is as telling as a good one.

  • Which clients have you worked with in my sector, and which journalists would you contact first about my topic?
  • Who will work on my account day to day, with what experience, and for how many other clients?
  • What angles do you see in my news, and which ones won't interest the press?
  • How do you keep your media list up to date?
  • What will my reporting look like, how often will I get it, and with which metrics?
  • Can I read coverage you obtained for a comparable client, and speak to that client?
  • What does the retainer include, how long is the commitment, and what is billed on top?
  • What happens if the first few months produce nothing?

After the meeting, ask for a short scoping note: two or three angles, the target media, the timeline for the first few months. In a few pages, it shows whether the agency has understood your subject.

What red flags should you watch out for?

  • Guaranteed coverage. A journalist alone decides what they publish. An agency commits to resources and a method, never to a specific article on a specific date; a guaranteed placement is advertising.
  • A wall of logos with no articles. Client names say nothing about the results obtained for them.
  • A list of thousands of contacts presented as an asset. Sending volume is not a network, and mass mailings end up being ignored.
  • A team that changes between the pitch and the kickoff. The person who won you over should be the one working on your account.
  • A press release proposed before any question about your goals. The agency is then selling execution, not advice.
  • Reporting that counts pitches sent or advertising value equivalency rather than the articles obtained and their effect on your goals.

Agency, freelancer or in-house press officer: which should you choose?

Three models coexist, and none of them is the best in absolute terms.

  • A freelance press officer suits a one-off announcement, a tight budget or a company that is just starting out: direct contact with a senior profile, flexibility, controlled cost. Their capacity is limited, and if they take on a big client or stop working, your schedule slips.
  • An agency brings a team, tools, continuity during holidays and the ability to work several angles in parallel. It costs more, and its value depends on the team actually assigned to your account.
  • An in-house press officer knows the product and responds quickly to journalists. The role makes sense with a steady flow of news; otherwise, the position runs idle, and if the person comes from another sector, their media network has to be built from scratch.

The right choice depends mainly on your stage and how often you make announcements. Our freelancer, agency or in-house press officer matrix (in French) cross-references your funding stage with the number of topics per month to help you decide.

What budget should you plan for?

Most agencies charge a monthly retainer with a commitment of a few months, and few publish their prices. To give you a sense of the market, our article on the cost of a B2B press relations campaign (in French) lists retainers of €2,500 to €4,500 a month for a seed-stage startup, €4,500 to €7,500 after a Series A or B round, and €6,500 to €10,000 for a mid-sized company. The same article puts the cost of a salaried junior press officer in Paris at between €50,000 and €65,000 a year, including employer contributions but excluding tools, and our decision matrix puts a senior freelancer at between €1,500 and €4,500 a month. These are observed ballpark figures, not a price list.

At 425PPM, our prices are public: three press relations packages at €3,500, €5,500 or €8,000 a month excluding VAT, with two to four dedicated consultants depending on the package, plus a one-time setup fee of €1,800 excluding VAT. The minimum commitment is three months, then month to month. The details of each package are on our pricing page.

Whatever the price, compare what it buys: the number and seniority of the people, the time spent on your account, the deliverables. A press relations budget pays for work and a method, never for a number of articles.

The right choice depends on your stage and your sector

A young company preparing its first funding round and an industrial company launching a low-carbon product line are not looking for the same agency. The first needs the business and tech press, on a tight schedule; the second needs its industry's specialist press and the regional press, over the long term.

At 425PPM, we work with impact companies, from startups to mid-sized companies. Both our prices and our clients' press coverage are public: you can check for yourself whether our references match your situation.

Two specific cases have their own page: press relations for startups and CSR press relations.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best press relations agency?

There isn't one that is best for everyone. The best agency for you knows your sector and its journalists, shows verifiable coverage for comparable clients and tells you who will work on your account. A ranking that does not spell out its criteria tells you none of this.

How long does it take to judge an agency's work?

With strong news, such as a funding round or a launch, the first articles can come out in the very first month. For a regular presence, allow three to six months, the time it takes to build relationships with the journalists in your sector. Judge the quality of the angles and of the exchanges with newsrooms first, then the coverage.

Can an agency guarantee press coverage?

No. A journalist alone decides what they publish. An agency can commit to resources (angles, journalists contacted, follow-ups, interviews arranged) and give ballpark figures drawn from its past campaigns, but it cannot promise a specific article on a specific date. A guaranteed placement is something you buy: it is advertising.

Press relations agency or communications agency: what's the difference?

A press relations agency works with journalists: angles, press releases, story pitches, interviews, coverage tracking. A communications agency covers a broader field, from advertising and social media to brand identity, and sometimes offers press relations among other services. If your goal is to get articles, ask what share of the team actually works with newsrooms.

Related articles

Learn more